World

Man who attacked nun on CCTV in Jerusalem acquitted on grounds of mental health

BBC World · 2026-08-27

AI SUMMARY

• What happened: An Israeli court acquitted Yona Schreiber, a Jewish man who attacked a nun in Jerusalem, citing he was experiencing a psychotic episode during the incident. • Why it matters: The attack, captured on CCTV, has raised concerns about religious coexistence in Jerusalem and highlighted increasing hostility towards Christian clergy and pilgrims in the area. • What to watch next: Observers will monitor the implications of this ruling on mental health accountability and the ongoing tensions between religious communities in Jerusalem, as well as any potential policy changes regarding the protection of religious minorities.

**Man Who Attacked Nun in Jerusalem Acquitted Due to Mental Health Issues**

An Israeli court has acquitted Yona Schreiber, a 36-year-old Jewish man, who was charged with assaulting a nun in Jerusalem earlier this year. The incident, which took place in April and was captured on CCTV, has drawn significant attention and condemnation due to its violent nature and the implications it has for religious coexistence in the city.

The Jerusalem Magistrates Court ruled that Schreiber was not criminally responsible for his actions at the time of the attack, citing that he was experiencing a psychotic episode. As a result, he has been ordered to be committed to a psychiatric hospital for a period of up to six years instead of facing criminal charges. The court's decision was influenced by a report from a district psychiatrist, which concluded that Schreiber was not fit to stand trial.

During the attack, Schreiber approached the French nun from behind, pushing her over and kicking her. The nun sustained bruises to her face and leg and hit her head on a stone block during the incident. Following the attack, the French Consulate in Jerusalem expressed strong condemnation, describing the act as aggressive and unacceptable.

The director of the French Biblical and Archaeological School, where the nun is affiliated as a researcher, characterized the assault as an "act of sectarian violence." The incident has raised alarms about the increasing hostility faced by Christian clergy and pilgrims in the Old City of Jerusalem, particularly from extremist elements within the Jewish community.

Israel's foreign ministry also condemned the attack, labeling it a "shameful act" that contradicts the values of respect, coexistence, and religious freedom that Israel claims to uphold. The ministry reaffirmed its commitment to ensuring that Jerusalem remains a city where all communities can worship and practice their faith safely and with dignity.

While such violent incidents are relatively rare, there has been a noted increase in harassment directed at Christians in Jerusalem's Old City. Reports indicate that there have been numerous instances of religious Jews displaying aggressive behavior towards individuals wearing Christian symbols or attire. Additionally, there have been cases of vandalism against church properties and disputes over property ownership involving settler groups, which church leaders argue threaten the established status quo regarding religious sites.

A report by the Rossing Center, an organization focused on improving interfaith relations in the region, highlighted a "recent surge in overt animosity towards Christianity," attributing this trend to rising polarization and ultra-nationalist political movements in Israel.

The acquittal of Yona Schreiber has sparked discussions about mental health, accountability, and the challenges of maintaining religious harmony in a city marked by deep historical and cultural significance for multiple faiths. As Jerusalem continues to navigate these complex dynamics, the incident serves as a reminder of the ongoing struggles for coexistence among its diverse communities.

Source: BBC World
RELATED NEWS

More Stories

All News
World

Al Jazeera reports from hospital in flood-hit Nepal

• What happened: Flash floods in Nepal have caused widespread damage and displacement, leading to many injuries and individuals reported missing, with emergency...

World

Satellite images show destruction from Nepal-Tibet floods

• What happened: A glacier collapse in the Himalayas triggered devastating floods across Nepal and Tibet, resulting in over 270 confirmed deaths and more than 1...

World

Nepal flash flood: dramatic footage shows Rasuwa valley engulfed

• What happened: A flash flood in Nepal's Rasuwa district on August 26 has resulted in at least 157 deaths and hundreds missing, following an ice and rock ...

World

Trial for 9/11 accused, including Khalid Sheikh Mohammed, set for June 2028

• What happened: A U.S. military judge has scheduled the trial for Khalid Sheikh Mohammed, the alleged mastermind of the September 11 attacks, and three co-defe...

World

Is Iran war diplomacy ramping up, as Qatar, Oman, Pakistan officials visit?

• What happened: High-level diplomatic visits to Tehran by officials from Qatar, Oman, and Pakistan are aimed at de-escalating tensions and reviving negotiation...

World

Norway’s King Harald in ‘extremely serious’ condition, palace says

• What happened: Norway's King Harald V, aged 89, is in "extremely serious" condition due to complications from a blood disease, specifically hae...